/logic-plan-critic

Criticize a workspace plan. Do not rewrite the plan. Do not implement.

Outcome

You hold a verdict: PASS, REVISE, or REJECT. The plan file is unchanged.

Assumptions

• A {slug}-plan.md exists.
• Skill file: .agents/skills/logic-plan-critic/SKILL.md
• MCP tools are visible.

Non-goals

• Do not rewrite the plan.
• Do not implement.
• Do not write the next artifact.

Contract

The critic is read-only. It re-queries hook_graph for blast radius. It does not trust the plan graph unverified.

Criticizing a plan is scope=IN.

Syntax

/logic-plan-critic

Plan: @tasks/bin-freeze-plan.md

∞AgentExtra High

If the slash name does not start the skill, put @.agents/skills/logic-plan-critic/SKILL.md on line 1.

Expected result: Findings with chapter and evidence. Then PASS, REVISE, or REJECT.

Fields

Rules to load

1. .agents/rules/mcp.md
2. .agents/rules/logic/thinking.md
3. .agents/rules/hook-utils-mcp.md
4. .agents/rules/logic/plan-format.md
5. .agents/rules/logic/grill.md
6. .agents/rules/logic/solution-proposal.md

Checklist

• Steelman the decision. Name the strongest objection, then whether it holds.
• Counterexamples: replay, missing document, partial failure, concurrency, empty input.
• Audit redundancies: duplicate hooks, overlapping fields, two owners for one artifact.
• Calculate overlaps. The same document must not be written in two phases. The same hook must not be updated twice.
• Blast radius 🟢 / 🟡 / 🔴 vs live upstream / downstream / references.
• Gradual order respected. Documents before hooks. Creates before deletes of dependents.
• Every phase has separation of concerns and testable logic gates.
• Rules loaded in the header match what the plan used.
• No invented paths, fields, or statuses.

Verdict

Verdict	When
REJECT	Gradual order violated, MCP skipped, or identity fields UNKNOWN
REVISE	Incomplete gates or understated blast
PASS	No blocker remains

Cite chapter and evidence.

Constraints

• If the verdict is not PASS, revise the plan. Do not start /hook-plan.
• research plans do not need this critic before stop. They have no implementation phases.

Errors

Problem	Cause	Action
Tools missing	MCP not registered	Stop. Fix Setup.
Plan graph trusted as-is	Critic skipped hook_graph	Re-run. Blast must be live.
REJECT on identities	Required field still UNKNOWN	Return to /logic-plan or /logic-discovery

Related

• /logic-plan
• /hook-plan after PASS when the change is a hook