/logic-plan-critic
criticizes a workspace plan
Plan
/logic-plan-critic
<plan>
@tasks/bin-freeze-plan.md
</plan>Point <plan> at {slug}-plan.md. The plan file stays unchanged.
Skill path
@.agents/skills/logic-plan-critic/SKILL.md
<plan>
@tasks/bin-freeze-plan.md
</plan>If the slash name does not start the skill, put the skill file on line 1.
Research
If the plan type is research, skip this skill. A research plan has no implementation phases.
Examples
/logic-plan-critic
<plan>
@tasks/bin-freeze-plan.md
</plan>Thought1s
The critic is read-only. Re-query hook_graph for blast radius.
Do not trust the plan graph. Do not rewrite the plan. Do not implement.
Worked for 1m 12s
Findings by chapter, with evidence.
Then a verdict: PASS, REVISE, or REJECT.
Bin freeze workspace plan
Source: live MCP `hook_graph` — `upstream` / `downstream` / `references`.
Cite chapter and evidence. Do not rewrite the plan.
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Gradual order | Documents before hooks. Creates before deletes of dependents. |
| Blast radius | Live graph vs the 🟢 / 🟡 / 🔴 claim in the plan |
| Overlap | The same document is not written in two phases. The same hook is not updated twice. |